deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour

Due to the large number of entries, should we have two lineart contest winners this month? 

65%
111 deviants said Yes, and the color portion of the contest should allow the contestant to color either one or both linearts. (Much like what was done with the "Wild" theme last summer)
14%
24 deviants said Yes, but the contestant should just be able to color only one lineart.
11%
19 deviants said No, we should only have one winner, and only one lineart for the color portion of the contest.
9%
16 deviants said Dude. Is this just another lame subversive ploy to get people to vote?

Devious Comments

:iconhotshadows:
~hotshadows Dec 3, 2007  Student Filmographer
Yes, but the contestant should just be able to color only one lineart.
i had such a good idea for a line art! but i really didn't have any time :(
Reply
:iconmylovestory:
I would have people be able to colour in both linearts and then have a winner for each of the linearts, but if you enter both times you can't win both times.
I'd think it would be fair that way. Plus people get to pick what lineart they want to colour in.
Reply
:iconloulou13:
*Loulou13 Dec 2, 2007  Hobbyist General Artist
Two winners .....Two choices.....In my book having choices gives one more variety. And maybe when choosing a winner for the coloured versions next month there could be two winners as well....One winner for each picture.
Reply
:iconcolor-me-club:
Yep. That's how we did it last time.
Reply
:iconloulou13:
*Loulou13 Dec 3, 2007  Hobbyist General Artist
Yes you did and it made alot of sense then.
Reply
:icongypsyleo:
Mood: Fear ~gypsyleo Dec 2, 2007   Digital Artist
When it gets to the stage of deciding which coloured picture is better, it will be far harder to choose when we are potentially faced with choosing from different images, as well as different artists variations on them.

At that point it really comes down to choosing which of the two images you like more, rather than choosing which colourization is more impressive.

Which is NOT the point of the Colour side of the contest.

One winner. Keep it simple, ******.
Reply
:iconcolor-me-club:
The color portion of the contest is also broken up. We have a winner for each image, as well.

Here's an old journal of the last time such a thing was done for the line/color contest.

[link]

We had two different images with two different voting periods. It was actually a ton of fun, and wasn't complicated at all.

`vest
:iconvest:
Reply
:iconrinoatalanheart993:
Yeah, I think it'd be good to have two winners. I think it would give the colourist a chance to pick one they're more comfortable with.
Reply
:iconagataka19:
two lineart winners is good. Like that people can choose which one they rather to color for contest, or both. IMO its good :)
Reply
:iconmewchild:
I wanted to vote the "Dude." one, but I figured I should actually cast a valid vote toward what I want. xD;;
Reply
Add a Comment:
 

Poll History